Does the perfect candidate exist? What the 37% rule teaches us about recruitment
The problem is simple: you only have one person to hire, and the candidates come one after the other, in an order you can't control. After each interview, you have to decide whether to make an offer or move on. If you reject a candidate, you can't go back to them. You know how they compare to the ones you've already seen, but you have no way of knowing if the next one will be better.
This is, in short, the secretary problem , a mathematical dilemma studied by statisticians and economists. The first known publication of the problem in its modern form dates back to 1960, in Martin Gardner's column in Scientific American ( Ferguson, 1989 ).
Sound familiar? If you keep looking, you risk missing out on a great candidate. If you stop too soon, you may never know what you missed. It's the dilemma of every recruiter or hiring manager, but math offers a surprising strategy for addressing it.
The 37% rule, explained with an apartment for rent
Imagine you want to rent an apartment. You have to visit several properties, good offers disappear quickly, and if you turn one down, there's no guarantee you'll have another chance to rent it. How do you decide when to stop looking?
Mathematics proposes a two-step strategy.
First, you explore: You analyze the first 37% or so of the options without choosing any. The goal is to understand what a good deal is in relation to your budget and criteria.
Then, you choose: After this stage, you accept the first offer that is better than all the ones you have seen so far.
Let's say you have 10 apartments to visit. You can't analyze exactly 37% of an apartment, so the optimal threshold is about 3 homes. You visit the first three without choosing any, then look for the first home that surpasses all the ones you've seen before.
Under these conditions, you have about a 40% chance of choosing the best apartment out of all 10. It is not a guarantee, but the probability resulting from the mathematical model.
And the interesting part? As the number of options increases, the optimal exploration ratio approaches 37%. The result remains roughly the same even when you have millions of options to choose from.
The strategy is known as the 37% rule and is an approximation of a mathematical solution based on constants.
But what if you don't know how many options you'll have?
In real life, you don't always know how many apartments will come on the market. In such situations, a related variation is the rule based on (1/e), approximately 36.8%, associated with the works of mathematician F. Thomas Bruss ( Bruss, 1984 ).
Imagine you set out to look for an apartment for 30 days. In a simplified model, you could use about the first 11 days to explore, then choose the first offer that beats the best one you've seen so far.
Be warned, though: this is a theoretical model, not a universal rule for finding a home. It works on the basis of assumptions about the emergence and evaluation of options. In reality, offers do not necessarily appear at a constant pace, and landlords are not obligated to wait for you.
However, the basic idea remains valuable: before you choose, you need a benchmark that helps you distinguish between a good option and one that only seems good because it's the first one.
The 37% Rule in Recruitment: Where It Doesn't Match Reality
If you've made it this far, you've probably already thought about how you could apply the strategy to a recruitment process. At first glance, it seems simple: you evaluate the first candidates, calibrate your expectations, and then choose the first one who outperforms everyone else you've seen.
But real recruitment is more complicated than a mathematical exercise. There are at least two important differences.
1. Candidates are not options that you can simply put aside.
Applied literally, the rule would mean not choosing any of the top 37% or so of candidates, even if you meet someone very suitable for the role.
In recruitment, this approach can be costly. A valuable candidate may receive another offer in the meantime, and postponing a good decision just to follow a formula doesn't always make sense.
Additionally, each candidate has their own experience in the recruitment process. Delayed communication or lack of response affects the perception of the company and can influence employer branding .
So, use the initial stage to calibrate your criteria, not to automatically reject the candidates who come up first. Evaluate them consistently and communicate your decisions in a timely manner.
2. You tend to stop too early.
Experimental research on search-stopping decisions shows that people do not always follow the optimal strategy and may end the search before the right time ( Seale and Rapoport, 1997 ).
In recruiting, this can easily happen. A candidate shows up who impresses in the first interview, the team gets excited, and the offer goes out before the recruiter has understood the market well enough or evaluated all the candidates already in the process.
The problem is not that you choose the first good candidate. The problem is that sometimes you haven't determined in advance what "good" means and you end up making the decision based on a momentary impression.
You need clear criteria and a process that helps you compare concrete evidence, not just impressions.
How to make better recruiting decisions with Busy Bee
A key detail of the secretary problem is that the decision becomes much simpler if you can keep all the options available until the end. In that case, you could compare the candidates and choose the best one from all those evaluated.
In recruiting, you can't assume that every candidate will wait until you've completed all the interviews. But you can organize the process so that you have a clear picture of the available options and don't lose important information along the way.
With Busy Bee's career site and applicant management tools, applications end up in one place, instead of being scattered across inboxes, messages, and Excel files.
You can track each candidate's progress, add notes, and keep relevant information at hand for your decision. So when it's time to compare candidates, you don't have to rely solely on memory or the impression left by your last interview.
Busy Bee doesn't choose the candidate for you or take the uncertainty out of recruiting. But it does provide you with a clearer, easier-to-follow process that helps you make informed decisions.
A simple process you can apply tomorrow
1. Define the criteria before the first interview.
Determine which skills are required, which are an advantage, and what evidence you’re looking for for each criterion. If you need a designer, for example, decide in advance how you’ll assess relevant experience, problem-solving ability, and team collaboration.
This way, you don't change your bar from one interview to another just because one candidate impressed you.
2. Use the first candidates for calibration.
The first interviews help you understand what the market looks like in relation to your requirements. Compare the profiles you encounter with your initial expectations and adjust the criteria if you find them unrealistic.
Don't automatically put off a great candidate just because they applied early. If they meet the essential criteria and you have enough evidence to make a decision, you don't have to wait for a certain number of interviews just for the sake of the formula.
3. Compare consistently, not intuitively.
Use the same criteria for all candidates and note concrete examples that support your assessment. An interview grid or simple scoring system can help you spot relevant differences between candidates and reduce the influence of momentary impressions.
4. Set a realistic deadline for the decision.
A process without a clear deadline can drag on indefinitely. Set a realistic recruitment timeline from the start and communicate it to those involved.
You don't need to interview a set number of candidates if you already have enough information to identify a suitable candidate. At the same time, don't rush into making an offer just because the first candidate seems promising.
Choose your deadline carefully. In the mathematical model, options are available under simplified assumptions. In recruitment, a good candidate has other opportunities, and a decision delayed too long can mean a lost offer.
Consider the complexity of the role, the availability of candidates, and the time required for the assessment. Find the balance between a well-informed decision and a process that is fast enough to avoid losing the right people.
What does the 37% rule actually teach us?
The 37% rule doesn't tell you who to hire. But it does remind you of something important: a good decision doesn't mean choosing the first candidate who impresses you, nor does it mean endlessly searching for a better one.
It means knowing what you're looking for, comparing consistently, and recognizing when you have enough information to decide.
And when you have a clear process and all the applications in one place, the decision no longer has to depend on memory, haste, or intuition.
With Busy Bee, you can manage your applicants in one place and more easily track every stage of your recruitment process. Try it for free and build a process where decisions are clearer and candidates don't get lost along the way.
Busy Bee — an ATS created specifically for teams that want to fly high
At Busy Bee, we built an ATS specifically for small and medium-sized companies that want to recruit smarter, not harder. Our platform helps you build an engaging career site and manage applications like a boss bee: with care, efficiency, and a healthy dose of organization.